Ingredients

What Does “Natural” Legally Mean on a Label?

What Does “Natural” Legally Mean on a Label?

“Natural” on a cosmetic label has no single legal definition anywhere in the EU. There’s no minimum percentage, no required test and no authority that checks the claim before a product reaches a shelf. That doesn’t make every use of the word meaningless. It does mean the word alone tells you far less than a certification logo next to it.

Not a protected term, but not unregulated either

Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, the EU’s core cosmetics law, doesn’t define “natural” or set a threshold a product must meet to use it. What it regulates is how any claim is made. Commission Regulation (EU) No 655/2013 sets six criteria every cosmetic claim has to meet: legal compliance, truthfulness, evidential support, honesty, fairness, and letting the customer make an informed decision.

So a brand can’t invent a percentage it can’t back up. But “natural” isn’t a regulated category the way a medicine’s dosage is. A product built mostly from plant-derived ingredients and one with a single natural extract stirred into a mostly synthetic base can both legally use the word, provided neither claim is false.

ISO 16128 is where a lot of the confusion sits. It’s an international standard that gives the industry a shared method for calculating how “natural” or “organic” an ingredient or finished product is, as a percentage. It separates a natural ingredient (from a plant, animal, mineral or microbial source, minimally processed) from a natural-origin one (started that way, then chemically modified), and gives a formula for combining them into an overall index.

What it doesn’t do is tell a brand when it may say “natural”. It isn’t a certification. A company can run the calculation internally, land on 80%, and print “natural” on the front without anyone outside checking that number.

What a certification adds that the word doesn’t

A certification like COSMOS is a different thing: a defined standard with published thresholds, audited by an accredited, independent body before the logo goes on the pack. That’s the structural difference. One is a claim a brand makes about itself; the other is a bar checked by someone with no stake in the sale.

We’ve explained what the COSMOS logo certifies, and the difference between its Organic and Natural tiers: two thresholds under the same standard, not one a lesser version of the other. COSMOS isn’t the only scheme. Ecocert, Soil Association, BDIH, Cosmebio and others each run their own audited standard with real differences in what they require, and our comparison of COSMOS, Ecocert and Soil Association shows which ones overlap.

Because there’s no gate to walk through, “natural” means different things depending on who’s printing it. It can be a specific, disclosed percentage against a real standard. It can be one plant extract added for the word. Or it can be a mood conveyed through packaging and colour, with nothing calculated behind it.

None of these is necessarily illegal, as long as nothing false is stated outright. That’s exactly why the word alone isn’t a reliable filter.

How to check a “natural” claim yourself

  • Look for a specific, disclosed percentage. “Up to 99% natural-origin ingredients” is checkable in a way “natural formula” isn’t.
  • Check whether that percentage is calculated against a named standard, such as ISO 16128, rather than left undefined.
  • Look for a third-party certification logo rather than a bare word, if independent verification matters to you.
  • Read the ingredient list itself. The first several ingredients by volume tell you more than any word on the front, and our guide to reading an ingredient list shows what to look for.
  • Remember that “natural” says nothing about gentleness. Plenty of natural-origin ingredients, essential oils among them, are known irritants, while several synthetic ones are mild and well tolerated. Origin and behaviour on skin are different questions.

Keep “natural” and “organic” apart too. People use them interchangeably, but they answer different questions even under one certification standard. “Natural” describes an ingredient’s origin and processing. “Organic” means grown under a defined agricultural standard without particular pesticides or synthetic fertilisers: a claim about farming method, not about how processed the final ingredient is. COSMOS’s own Organic and Natural tiers are the clearest worked example of that distinction.

Quick questions

  • Is it illegal to call a cosmetic “natural” in the EU? Not on its own. No EU law defines the word or sets a required percentage. What’s regulated is whether the overall claim is truthful and not misleading. A brand can be challenged for a false or unsubstantiated claim, but not simply for using the word.
  • Does ISO 16128 mean a product is certified natural? No. It’s a calculation method for working out a naturality percentage. It isn’t a certification scheme, doesn’t involve independent auditing, and doesn’t authorise any specific label wording on its own.