Ingredients

Reading a Skincare Label: What to Actually Check

Reading a Skincare Label: What to Actually Check

Stand in front of a skincare shelf and you’re reading two documents at once. The front of the box is a short list of confident words chosen by people whose job is to sell you the thing. The ingredient panel on the back, usually in tiny type, is the only part written to a legal standard.

Almost everyone reads the first one. The second is where the information is, including which front-of-box words are backed by an audit, which by a definition, and which by very little. Some words in that last group are ones our own corner of the industry leans on heavily, and we’d rather say so than let a nice-sounding word do work it hasn’t earned.

What the ingredient list tells you

Every cosmetic sold in the EU carries a list of ingredients in INCI names, the shared international system that makes “Aqua” mean the same thing in Lisbon as in Helsinki. It’s there so the same ingredient can’t hide behind fifteen different marketing names.

The order is real for the first few lines. The Cosmetics Regulation requires the list to run in descending order of weight, measured at the point each ingredient is added to the batch. Then comes the caveat: anything present at under 1% may be listed in any order, and nothing on the label marks where that line falls.

So the top of an ingredient list is a ranking and the bottom is just a set. If the extract you were sold on appears twenty-second out of twenty-four, its position tells you nothing about how it compares to the one listed twenty-third. Both are somewhere under one per cent, in an order the manufacturer was free to choose. As a rough guide, once you reach preservatives, pH adjusters, gums and thickeners, and individually named scent compounds, you’re usually below that line.

Our own Sensitive Skin Moisturiser opens with aloe leaf juice, then glycerin, then jojoba seed oil; water appears eleventh. Most face creams lead with Aqua, and if that matters to you, the panel is the only place that tells you. The asterisks next to the aloe and jojoba mark ingredients from organic farming, a convention that comes from certification schemes rather than the Cosmetics Regulation itself. Our ingredients page explains every ingredient we use.

Three conventions people routinely misread. Colourants other than hair dyes may be listed in any order after everything else, and a shade range may list every pigment used across the whole range, so a pigment on the label might not be in the pot in your hand. Ingredients present as nanomaterials must be followed by the word “nano” in brackets; if it isn’t there, they aren’t present in that form. And parfum is one word for many, which gets its own section below.

Certified, and the words that only sound like it

Third-party certification exists because neither “natural” nor “organic” has a legal definition for cosmetics in the EU. The EU organic rules cover agriculture and food, not face cream, and the Cosmetics Regulation sets no threshold for how natural anything has to be.

COSMOS is the main certification you’ll meet on European shelves, audited by an independent body rather than declared by the brand. The two-second check in a shop: a certified product prints its natural-origin and organic percentages near the logo, rather than the logo standing alone. Our explainer on what COSMOS does and doesn’t certify goes further.

“Natural” on its own is meaningless as a technical claim: no legal definition, no minimum threshold. There’s an ISO guideline for calculating natural and organic content, but it’s a guideline, not a certification, and nobody audits you against it.

“Dermatologically tested” deserves more care than it usually gets, in both directions. European Commission guidance says the claim implies testing on humans under a dermatologist’s supervision, with evidence the brand has to hold. What it doesn’t tell you is the shape of that test: no standardised protocol, no required number of participants, no obligation to publish anything. “Well tolerated by the panel” is a real statement. It isn’t the same as “suitable for your skin.”

“Hypoallergenic” works similarly. Commission guidance says it may only be used where a product is designed to minimise allergenic potential, with evidence kept up to date, but the same guidance is blunt that it doesn’t guarantee the absence of a reaction.

Free-from claims, “chemical-free” included, are more restricted than people assume. Under EU guidance, “free from parabens” should not be accepted, because it denigrates a group of legally permitted, safety-assessed ingredients. Free-from claims are acceptable where they support an informed choice, such as “free from animal-derived ingredients” for vegans.

Parfum is the most important word on the panel

If your skin reacts and you learn only one thing here, learn this. A whole perfume composition can be listed under the single term “parfum” or “aroma”, standing for dozens of individual scent materials the panel isn’t required to break out.

The exception is the useful part. Scent compounds that EU rules require to be declared must appear by name in addition to parfum, once they exceed 0.001% in a leave-on product or 0.01% in a rinse-off one. Those are the names that puzzle people: limonene, linalool, geraniol, citral. They’re usually components of the fragrance itself, often naturally occurring in essential oils, named because they’re recognised sensitisers for some people.

Labels are getting longer for a reason. The list of scent compounds that must be declared by name has expanded to more than eighty entries, with products newly placed on the EU market required to comply from 31 July 2026. That’s more disclosure, not more allergens. The same formula that listed two names may now list six, with nothing added to it.

“Fragrance-free” and “unscented” aren’t interchangeable. Fragrance-free is a free-from claim that has to meet the common criteria. Unscented isn’t defined anywhere, and a product can smell of nothing while still containing scent materials. The panel settles it either way. We made our Sensitive Skin Moisturiser fragrance-free deliberately, and its panel carries no parfum and no declared scent compounds, which you can verify without trusting us.

Vegan, cruelty-free, and the small print nobody reads

Vegan and cruelty-free get printed side by side so often that people read them as one idea, but they answer different questions. Vegan is about what’s in the formula: no animal-derived ingredients. There’s no EU legal definition of the term for cosmetics, so it may be a brand’s own declaration or a third-party mark, but you can check it against the panel.

Cruelty-free is about testing, and in the EU it’s close to meaningless as a differentiator, because it’s the legal floor. Animal testing of cosmetic ingredients and finished products has been prohibited since March 2013, and EU guidance says a brand shouldn’t present mere compliance with minimum legal requirements as a specific benefit.

The legally required bits almost nobody reads are on every compliant product, and each is a small piece of accountability:

  • a responsible person named with an EU address;
  • a batch number that makes a recall traceable;
  • a best-before date or an open-jar symbol showing how many months a product stays good after opening (“12M” means twelve months from opening, not from purchase);
  • a hand-on-book symbol pointing to an enclosed leaflet;
  • a statement of what the product is for, where that isn’t obvious from the packaging.

If you have sensitive skin and thirty seconds

In order of how much each will tell you:

  1. Find parfum or aroma and look for named scent compounds after it. It’s the highest-yield ten seconds on the whole panel.
  2. Read the first five ingredients, which are ranked and make up most of the formula.
  3. If there’s a certification logo, look for the percentages beside it. A logo with no numbers deserves a second look.
  4. Treat “dermatologically tested” and “hypoallergenic” as meaning something real to the manufacturer, not as tie-breakers you can check.
  5. Patch test anyway. Nothing on any label, ours included, predicts how your skin will respond to a specific formula.

None of this makes shopping for skincare quick, and a shorter ingredient list isn’t automatically a kinder one. What reading a label buys you is less guessing. Certifications count because someone independent checked them, the regulated symbols because someone is accountable for them. Most of the rest of the front of the box is typography.

Two more things to look for on the back. Squalane and squalene look almost identical on a label but behave very differently in a formula. And the open-jar symbol is one of the few regulated bits of packaging; our guide to the PAO symbol and what its number means covers it.